« Previous | Main | Next »

Simple Plan - 'Your Love Is A Lie'

Post categories:

Fraser McAlpine | 10:09 UK time, Friday, 18 April 2008

Simple PlanHaha! This is amazing! You know how 'Boulevard Of Broken Dreams' by Green Day and 'Wonderwall' by Oasis seem to share the same musical parents? (It came up in a really old ChartBlog posting, from the days when we were still pink.) Well, it looks like they've got a new baby brother, and typical of the younger generation, he's into all breaks and beats and drum machines and whatnot. Noel Gallagher would be spinning in his grave if he were only a) dead or b) on a roundabout, in a grave.

Naturally, we here at ChartBlog do not care what Noel Gallagher thinks about plagiarism. Charming and eloquent though the man is, and undoubtedly a deserving member of the Rock Star Club and all round Good Bloke, it's not really a topic he can comment on without drawing a certain amount of ridicule upon himself. And the less said about his stance on Jay-Z at Glastonbury, the better, really.

So, this just leaves us pondering how best to enjoy this song. We can either listen to it intently, shouting out "WONDERWALL!" or "BOULEVARD!" whenever the membrane of recognition gets punctured (pretty much all the time, I've tried it). Or we can just relax, admit that there are similarities but that everyone gets their ideas from somewhere, and enjoy the musical experience as a whole.

Personally, once I've finished pointing and giggling, I'm all for the latter approach. You've got to think kindly of a song which has pop verses and rock choruses, it's like a half-way house for people who are undecided as to which they like the most.

Which makes this the musical equivalent of THAT MOMENT in Harry Hill's TV Burp. You know the one...

"So we've got rock, hmm? Yes? And pop...but which is best? There's only one way to find out..."

"FIIIIIGHT!"

I expect Noel Gallagher is against THAT too....

Three starsDownload: Out now
CD Released: April 21st
www.simpleplan.com
www.myspace.com/simpleplan

(Fraser McAlpine)

Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    So what you're saying is that this is a rip off but it still gets three stars? Similar to the Hoosiers song "sampling" the Cure?

    Does that mean that being a musician doesn't need to involve actually writing music anymore? Good grief anyone can do it then.

    In which case just imagine these words set to the tune of .. oh I don't know, "Hey Jude", and can I have my cheque now?

    John.

  • Comment number 2.

    Two different reviewers, two different star ratings, Thranj. Although it's the same point...

    As for your 'Hey Jude' song...well, it depends on how well I'm imagining you singing it.

    At present it's so bad that you owe ME money...

  • Comment number 3.

    This song's quite good really, the wonderwall/boulevard moment for me comes in at around 0:33. As with the Hoosiers using Lovecats, there are worse songs to copy. Wonderwall is a great song, although it has never been the same since I was informed that it was "saves me" not "sainsburys".

    Olivia

    P.S That Harry Hill reference didn't half make me laugh, that man's pure genius.

  • Comment number 4.

    Actually Frasier I was imagining Harry Hill singing it, which, to be fair, I would pay for.

    (You are quite right, if I was singing anything I would owe everyone a fortune).

    John.

  • Comment number 5.

    Haha! I KNEW it!

    I also love Harry Hill. He's amazing.

  • Comment number 6.

    It just makes me kind of angry and kind of sad that artists with such undoubted talent need to reference other music so obviously.

    Both this song and the Hoosiers' song have good lyrics, but if you spend all your time listening to this song comparing it to another (arguably) better song then you don't appreciate the lyrics or the original touches. It seems a waste, to me.

    John

    PS. I seem to be turning into a Tears for Fears song at the start of this comment, for which I apologise profusely.

    PPS. Is there anything people do profusely other than sweat or apologise?

  • Comment number 7.

    Hah.. being a musician never involved WRITING music. Entire orchestras make their living by playing a dead guy's tunes.. tell them that they're not musicians and watch how grouchy they get..

  • Comment number 8.

    Oh and tons of things can be done profusely.. bleeding for one.

  • Comment number 9.

    Ah but you don't often hear of people rueing anything but 'the day'


    Or of people being quintissentially anything other than English. I love these sort of cul-de-sac words.

    Shall we make a list?

  • Comment number 10.

    Hmm I've heard quintessential romantic before. Not much else though really.

    On rue you win lol.. and gaw.. I can't think of anymore like that =/

  • Comment number 11.

    Hi,

    yes, i know you don't need to write music to be a musician. That wasn't what I said.

    As for the cul-de-sac words...

    meted out : treatment or punishment.

    stone-cold: sober or Steve Austin

    indefinable: something

    fatal: flaw (or rather, what is a flaw if not fatal?)

    and has anyone ever been gruntled?


    John


  • Comment number 12.

    I have once. But I'm not doing it again.

  • Comment number 13.

    What was it you did say then?
    That's what it sounded like you were saying..


    The gruntled thing is like the overwhelmed/underwhelmed/just whelmed thing. Strange words.

  • Comment number 14.

    I didn't say it. What I said was

    "It just makes me kind of angry and kind of sad that artists with such undoubted talent need to reference other music so obviously."

    I mean I can't enjoy the good work they are doing because I keep thinking about the other song while their song is on. It's just how it is for me.

    Obviously, like an orchestra, nothing is stopping them from playing other people's music, but symphony orchestras don't usually claim to have written the music they are playing, although they may have rearranged it enough to claim some artistic credit.

    I may be wrong, both bands may have writing credits to the original songs on the singles. That I don't know.

    John

 

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.