Reducing the dangers of journalism: a view from Pakistan

Wednesday 17 October 2012, 17:14

Hamid Mir Hamid Mir is executive editor of Pakistan’s Geo News television channel

When I got my first death threat almost two decades ago I didn’t take it too seriously. It was an exciting time to be a journalist. Since then I have lost several jobs, mainly due to my writing and journalistic endeavors as a television anchor.

I was banned by the military regime of General Pervez Musharraf from appearing on television because of my pro-democracy talk shows. I was even kidnapped in war zones by the Afghan Taliban and the Hezbollah. But I am lucky enough to have ducked all such dangers successfully, so far.

For me, journalism is not a profession but a passion. The year 2009 was a turning point in my career when my passion greatly depressed my family members as well as friends. I was declared a traitor by the all-powerful intelligence agencies, primarily because I was constantly raising the issue of the missing persons through my columns and talk shows.

While religious fanatics threatened to kill me because of my opposition to their high-handed tactics, the then US ambassador to Pakistan also wrote a letter against me to the management of my television channel. The US envoy was actually upset over some blunt questions I had posed to the visiting US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in a television interview.

I was literally in the middle of crossfire at that time. I had never imagined that I would be warned by my closest friends not to speak the truth, otherwise I would be eliminated. Some top government officials compelled me to restrict my movements and stop going to the office.

In the past year I have received numerous phone calls from senior government officials informing me that I face serious threats to my life and that I should be careful while speaking on television and writing for newspapers. There was a time when believed I could be provided with protection against threats by the law enforcement agencies. But I have lately realised that nothing can be done to protect media persons when state agencies themselves decide to bully them.

Dozens of daring journalists have been kidnapped and killed in my country by the state and non-state actors in the name of ‘national interest’. I am lucky to be still alive, maybe because I live in Islamabad, the capital, and not in the Baluchistan or Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provinces or Karachi, which are considered to be dangerous places for journalists.

More than 80 Pakistani journalists have lost their lives in the line of duty in the past ten years, including some close friends of mine. Media persons discharging their professional duties in a conflict zone have the power to influence the lives of millions. But this equally puts their own lives at risk, especially in countries such as Pakistan where the most extreme form of censorship is to kill a journalist to silence their voice.

As things stand, a large majority of journalists in Pakistan feel unsafe, with dozens having already been forced to quit their profession or leave their home town in a bid to save their life. Journalists are under threat not only from fanatical terrorists and criminals but the state-run intelligence agencies.

But the safety of journalists is a matter of grave concern for all mainstream journalism bodies across the globe. In the past decade more than 1,000 media persons have been killed worldwide. Unfortunately, most of them were the victims of targeted killings.

It is time for the United Nations to force its member states to take all possible measures to bring their domestic media-related laws into line with international standards. The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) adopted resolution No. 1738 in 2006 to establish a coherent, action-oriented approach to the safety of journalists in conflict zones. But it is unfortunate to note that hardly any action has been taken by the UN against a member state for violating this resolution.

A special prosecutor was appointed in Mexico a few years back to control crimes against the media, but they need to improve their performance. A journalist protection bill was introduced in the Iraqi parliament last year, but this law failed to offer any meaningful protection to journalists. The National Union of Journalists in India is also demanding special laws for the protection of journalists.

As far as the Pakistan government is concerned, it has recently promised to introduce a Journalists’ Protection Bill in the parliament - but it seems to be a lengthy process.

The following are a few of the many steps which can be taken by governments and official bodies, as well as media organisations and journalists themselves, to ensure the safety of media persons:

Governments:

  • Member states of the UN should legislate to guarantee media freedom, including freedom of expression and freedom of opinion. The drafting and application of such laws should take due account of the fundamental right to freedom of opinion and expression. Journalists should have the right to protect their sources
  • Governments should link the placing of official advertisements with media houses to their provision of high-quality safety measures for their workers
  • Media organisations should be made to ensure that the journalists who are working in conflict areas have full life insurance which covers illness, repatriation, disability and loss of life.

Media organisations:

  • All media organisations should arrange regular training courses and workshops for their staff working in conflict areas
  • Assignments in conflict areas should only be given to committed professionals who have been given a choice in accepting the role
  • Media persons working in dangerous environments should have reliable safety equipment (bullet-proof jackets, helmets) including satellite phones, communication equipment (locator beacons) and first aid kits
  • Media organisations should either depute a safety adviser or appoint a high-risk team to stay in touch with all journalists working in conflict zones and to provide them with necessary support whenever required
  • Every media organisation should have a code of conduct for discouraging unethical practices in the name of journalism. It will provide credibility and help increase respect, which is the biggest shield against state and non-state threats.

Journalists and other media workers:

  • During big demonstrations and riots, journalists should display identity cards prominently
  • Immediately after an IED explosion, reporters and cameramen should stay away from the blast site because a second blast usually follows the first one to ensure maximum loss of life
  • Journalists must cover conflicts objectively with a balanced approach. One-sided reporting always invites trouble in conflict zones. Media persons should try to avoid embedded journalism: sometimes security forces and militants try to dictate their own point of view which can prove dangerous for newsmen
  • Journalists should not move around in conflict areas without local guides and translators (I was kidnapped twice in Afghanistan and Pakistan by the Taliban but was able to return home safely mainly because my translator convinced them that I was not a spy)
  • Media workers should always carry relevant travel and identity documents while reporting in another country. I have never entered Afghanistan without a valid passport and visa, unlike other foreign journalists who were taken hostage by the Afghan Taliban because they didn’t bother to get visas
  • Journalists should always stay in touch with their editor or chief reporter during a risky assignment: these people should be aware of their movements and circumstances
  • In case of a threat from an individual or institution, media workers should immediately inform their editor in writing, naming those behind the threat. They should also email or record a video statement, and give it to a trusted organisation or friend
  • Anyone who feels that somebody can target them on the way to the office should change their timing and route as a precautionary measure. Also, it is advisable to remove any name plate outside the house
  • Anyone who feels their organisation or the authorities cannot protect them should approach local journalism bodies or international organisations such as the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) or Reporters Sans Frontiers (RSF). They can publicise a case internationally to dissuade those who are trying to threaten them.

It goes without saying that risk is the beauty of journalism. However, no story is worth your life. I made a blunder in Lebanon in 2006 when I tried to film the Israeli bombing of the Hezbollah headquarters by entering a no-go area. I was arrested by the Hezbollah forces and imprisoned in a jail that was hit by the Israeli missiles.

In my opinion, the true quality of democracy in a country can be gauged by the security and protection of its media persons. Threats, intimidation and violence directed against journalists signify an attack on democracy itself.

When newsgathers can act as the eyes and ears of society without facing fear, they become agents of democracy and freedom. But when they are made to perform their duties in an atmosphere of fear it severely affects the free flow of information on which democracies are founded.

Media persons across the globe need to feel free and safe so that they can efficiently perform their roles as the agents of democracy and freedom.

Front-line journalists and senior editors are meeting this week at the BBC College of Journalism to discuss journalist safety ahead of a UN meeting in November where the issue will be debated.

There's more about those meetings in a previous post by William Horsley.

Comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 1.

    Always pray for your safty you Hamir mir and Talat hussain are always speaks truth and always supported the Public of South Waziristan Mahsud,
    Both of you are in our Prayers, .

    From A mahsud , Kacha langer khail , Tehseel ladah, South Waziristan agencey,.

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 2.

    Hamid Mir you are one of the few journalist who are an asset of Pakistan. I really appreciate you devotion for the cause of Pakistan and love to read when you say "for me, journalism is not a profession but a passion". And as you said in this article that "risk is the beauty of journalism. However, no story is worth your life" Therefore, be safe. We all suuport your cause and pray for your safety.

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 3.

    I really aperciate your work Sir, And when I started watching news channels in 2007. I watch your programs daily. I knew you are very brave person. But you should also take care of life threats. You are needed for us. You are the only who speak for Balochs for us. I really salute you... Thanks

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 4.

    The reporter should be objective in reporting.He should not colour the report by his personal likes and dislikes. A journalist must also give due importance to the views and responsibilities of the government.You cannot always have ideal conditions in places like Pakistan where iverse forces are at work.The interest of the country should be at the top even if it requires your personal principles.

  • Comment number 5.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

 

Comments 5 of 6

 

This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

Previous
How to be interviewed: a last word on the party conference season

Tuesday 16 October 2012, 11:33

Next
Brazilian experience: investigative journalists struggle to enhance journalists’ safety

Wednesday 17 October 2012, 16:46

About this Blog

A blog for the College of Journalism at the BBC Academy, discussing current technical, ethical, production and craft issues in journalism.

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?

Follow us on Twitter

New twitter image News and comment about journalism and interaction with the College:

@BBCCollege

Recent posts from this blog

TECHNOLOGY

Google Glass by Charles Miller

iOS 7 for journalists by Marc Settle

Responsive web design by Helene Sears

Viral videos by Charles Miller

ETHICS

Use of violent footage by Charles Miller

Reporting transgender issues by Stuart Hughes

Pitfalls of data journalism by Martin Rosenbaum

Is Twitter sexist? by Anna Holligan

INTERNATIONAL

What President Putin never says by Stephen Ennis

BBC emboldens Pakistan media by Sajid Iqbal

Twitter in the Arab world by Damian Radcliffe

Media freedom in Turkey by William Horsley

JOURNALISM IN PRACTICE

Newsnight enlists social media by Anna Holligan

Coverage of high tech burger by Rebecca Wells

Healthy hyperlocal media by Damian Radcliffe

Media access to Google by Charles Miller

Waiting for the royal baby by Suzanne Lord

TIPS AND GUIDES

Place name pronunciation by Marieke Martin

Researching science topics by Alex Freeman

Americanisms and the BBC by Ian Jolly

Researching Northern Ireland by Tim Shields

Also from the College

Polly Evans on presenting regional news for BBC South East Today

Polly Evans

 

How the BBC provides impartial coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict

Jerusalem

Alan Green on the job of a football commentator for BBC Radio 5 Live

Alan Green

 

The BBC College of Journalism and New York Times social media conference in New York

The College of Journalism's New York conference

Blogroll

Other great places to follow debates about journalism and media:

George Brock: thoughts on journalism past, present and future from City University's head of journalism

The Media Blog: lively and often funny topical detail about UK media output

Memex 1.1: John Naughton’s online diary: comment on media output and technology from the journalist and academic

Arab Media & Society: Arab media and trends summarised by the American University in Cairo

British Journalism Review: selected pieces from the authoritative quarterly journal

MediaShift: PBS monitoring of the changing media world from a US perspective

Arts & Letters Daily: more interesting ideas and good writing than you will ever have time to read

FiveThirtyEight: Nate Silver of the New York Times writes data-based US politics blog (there are 538 electors in the US electoral college)

Alltop Journalism: links to the most recent posts on many journalism blogs

About the BBC: varied BBC blog about all things BBC-ish

Columbia Journalism Review: US academic perspectives

Facebook + Journalists: Facebook's own guide to its use by journalists

Andy Dickinson: teacher of digital and online journalism at the University of Central Lancashire

Jon Slattery: UK media news from the former deputy editor of Press Gazette

Meeja Law: Judith Townend's guide to media and legal issues 

European Journalism Centre: global news from the Netherlands

Roy Greenslade: Guardian blog by the former Mirror editor now journalism prof

Wannabee Hacks: information and experiences from aspiring journalists.