Has the final whistle been blown on What Happened Next?

Thursday 11 April 2013, 16:09

Gareth Edwards Gareth Edwards Producer

Tagged with:

In recent weeks many viewers of A Question Of Sport have been commenting on Twitter and other sites that they miss the 'What Happened Next?' round and are wondering why it is no longer a regular feature in the programme. This blog is my way of trying to respond to those comments and explain why it has only appeared in a handful of shows over the past 12 months.

'What happened next?’ Barely a weekend goes by without a sporting correspondent somewhere in the UK referring to it in their commentary when a mistake or blooper takes place. It is equally common to hear it on the amateur sports fields of the country. It is certainly the case where I play club cricket when an easy catch is dropped. 

The famous round on A Question of Sport has been a crowd favourite since the early days of the programme back in the 1970s. To be perfectly honest when we look back at some of those early shows the What Happened Next? footage wasn't exactly side-splittingly humourous. Early examples include a Manchester United match when the teams saw Bobby Charlton frozen in time as he is about to send a cross over into the box...what happened next? Was there a streaker? Did the goalkeeper's shorts fall down? Did the referee cop one in the face? No to all those, the rather tepid answer was that Denis Law headed in a rather run of the mill goal. A more innocent time perhaps? 

Over the years the round developed and fast became a beacon of light-heartedness amid a sea of sporting trivia. During the ‘80s and ‘90s most viewers can remember Botham, Beaumont or McCoist coming up with all manner of possibilities to the outcome of the frozen sports footage. The sports involved became far more varied and the teams and people involved came from all four corners of the globe. I remember one of my first jobs as a researcher on the show (probably in late 1999) was to track down and find the footage from an international football match involving Hong Kong and Macao. I also remember the 2002 Commonwealth Games for some reason being a gold mine of sporting blunders.

However in recent years with the advent of 24-hour News along with YouTube, Twitter and other social media sites these incidents, no matter where in the world they come from, are all over the internet and television within minutes. Recently there was an interruption in a Swiss League football match where a rodent invaded the pitch and was chased around by the players before eventually biting one of them on the finger.

Pine Marten

Quite simply this is the kind of incident that What Happened Next? was made for. Within 24 hours of this game being played the video was a YouTube phenomenon, people's Twitter feeds were full of links to the story and the player involved had been interviewed on radio and television. The problem with using this footage in the quiz is once we have recorded a show there is normally a 3-4 week period before transmission, sometimes longer. By which stage the world and his wife will have seen the clip countless times, making our show look very dated.

Another problem is that some of the biggest Tweeters are sports people, none more so than our captain Matt Dawson. So the probability that they will have seen it, or retweeted it, by the time they are on the panel is high. I had already accepted that funnies from the Premier League, 6 Nations, Wimbledon or any of the major sporting events were no longer possibilities – their profile and coverage is simply too great. However when that sphere of exclusion starts to include Swiss football then our options do start to become very limited. 

As the Series Producer I am desperately keen to still try and include WHN? within the show whenever possible. Maybe we will have to dig further to find gems like this golf clip from the Women's European Tour

We are not throwing in the towel on What Happened Next? just yet.…


Gareth Edwards is Series Producer of A Question of Sport, the next episode is broadcast on Wednesday 17 April, on BBC One.

Tagged with:


Jump to comments pagination

This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

Sony Radio Academy Awards 2013 Nominations

Wednesday 10 April 2013, 15:19

Why we're playing 'Ding Dong The Witch is Dead' on Radio 1's Sunday 14 April 2013 Chart Show

Friday 12 April 2013, 14:35

About this Blog

This blog explains what the BBC does and how it works. We link to some other blogs and online spaces inside and outside the corporation. The blog is edited by Jon Jacob.

Follow About the BBC on Twitter

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?

External links about the BBC

Doctor Who's new web game aims to teach children programming skills (Guardian)
"Latest attempt to make coding fun for kids involves rescuing a Dalek and exploring the unscreened world of Sontar"

BBC boss Danny Cohen hits back at Children in Need 'hidden millions' claims: 'Vulnerable children could suffer' (Mirror)

Strictly Come Dancing triumphs over The X Factor again in ratings battle (Independent) 

The Vamps win big at Radio 1 Teen Awards (MTV)

BBC adds chat app to Ebola effort (Ariel)
"World Service has turned to instant messenger to get the latest word on Ebola out to audiences in West Africa."

Broadcasters Reveal Leaders' Debate Plan (KL.FM)
"Sky News, the BBC, ITV and Channel 4 have announced joint plans for a series of party leader debates across TV and the internet in the run-up to the 2015 General Election."

BBC3 orders six docs from new directors for Fresh strand (Televisual)
"BBC3 has commissioned six new one-off documentaries for its Fresh strand – the channel’s scheme for new directors looking for a break into prime-time film-making."

Brainy BAMEs upskill (Ariel)

Pharrell, One Direction, Sam Smith And Pretty Much Everyone You’ve Ever Heard Of Beautifully Cover "God Only Knows" (Buzzfeed)
"Don’t blink, you might miss Elton John covered in butterflies or Lorde wearing angel wings"

Alan Sugar's not looking for 'donkeys' (Ariel)

BBC iPlayer catch-up window extended to 30 days

Strictly Come Dancing 2014: Gregg Wallace is first celebrity to leave the show (Radio Times)
"The MasterChef presenter fails to cook up enough votes to ensure his survival as Mrs Browns Boys star Jennifer Gibney beats him in the dance-off"

Martin Freeman to Star in BBC Drama About Trial of Adolf Eichmann (Hollywood Reporter)

BBC's casting coup: Sir Anthony Hopkins and Sir Ian McKellen unite (Telegraph)

BBC launches Young Dancer 2015 competition (Digital Spy)
"the BBC is working with top names in dance to develop a programme that will not only find the young dance performers of the future, but give them a real break at the very start of their professional careers"

Conway to head up BBC Studios and Post Production (Televisual)
"I’m looking forward to working with the BBC S&PP team to further stabilise the business after several years of exceptional transformation and change"

First Look At Benedict Cumberbatch As Richard III In The Hollow Crown (Empire)

Sheila Tracy, the first woman to read the news on Radio 4, dies (Telegraph)

Sheila Tracy, the first woman to read the news on Radio 4, dies (Telegraph)

Radio 2 Live In Hyde Park attracted record 1.19m Red Button viewers (Musicweek)
"These numbers bear testimony to us having secured this broad and distinctive line-up of artists who are bang on target for our audience on air, online and on TV"

End of an era: BBC letters taken down from Television Centre in Shepherd's Bush after 54 years (Evening Standard)

Eniola Aluko makes history as first female Match of the Day pundit (Guardian)

Artists Make Works Using BBC Archive (Artnet News)

BBC confirms Sinead Rocks as controller of Learning (Prolific North)

Last updated Monday 20 October 2014

Blogs from across the BBC

Selected by the About the BBC Blog team.

BBC to launch 'The Doctor and the Dalek' game for kids [Doctor Who]
Weather: Redirecting mobile users to responsive [Internet]
Google's 'right to be forgotten' tour comes to London [Academy]
Encouraging your children's language and comprehension skills through shared book reading [CBeebies Grown-ups]
The vegetables of truth [Adam Curtis]

MatOf ThDay At 50: onic theme even has a banjo [TV]