Looking ahead to the next prime ministerial debates

Friday 28 May 2010, 10:21

Luba Kassova Luba Kassova

Tagged with:

David Cameron, Nick Clegg and Gordon Brown at The Prime Ministerial Debate
More than 22m people watched any of the three prime ministerial debates that took place in the run up to the election. It's hard to tell what kind of impact the debates had on voting behaviour - voter turnout was up on 2005 from 61.4% in 2005 to 65.1% - but it is clear that the debates engaged viewers.

The success of the debates at this election makes them a very likely feature at the next, so we asked viewers what they thought of the debates.

The key themes that came back were a desire for more grilling of the leaders and a greater degree of audience participation. Many said that they wanted the moderator to be able to respond once the leaders had spoken.

The rigidity of the debate was a slight bugbear for audiences. Just a third thought the programmes were spontaneous or that there were surprising elements in the debate and a significant minority felt the staged responses and tight rules were a weakness of the debate.

Of course the rules of the debate aren't just for the broadcasters to decide - the parties themselves heavily influence this - but we will feed these views into discussions next time round.

Luba Kassova is Head of Audiences, Journalism

Tagged with:

Comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 1.

    My biggest criticism of these debates is that they replaced the Question Time with each individual leader on his or her own in front of the Question Time audience. I think we saw much more democracy when Tony Blair was obviously unaware of difficulties in making GP appointments.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 2.

    I found that the format for the Scottish leaders' debates worked a lot better than the prime ministerial ones. The moderator could grill the leaders and the audience could respond.

    However, one problem with loosening the rules for the prime ministerial debates is potential for a loss of impartiality. Obviously the BBC are the experts at impartiality; David Dimbleby gets lots of practice doing Question Time every week. But the other broadcasters (particularly Sky) aren't quite so good at it. There are plenty of examples of Sky getting it wrong, including Adam Boulton's treatment of Nick Clegg in their TV debate.

    I think the rules need to be a balance between giving the BBC space to properly grill the leaders, whilst preventing Sky from doing anything stupid.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 3.

    The leader's debate reminded me of another recent event.

    Besuited types with a vision of the future which has so little to do with the actual hopes and aspirations of the public. Ill-conceived ideas that seem designed to satisfy the right-wing media all conveyed without an opportunity for the audience to challenge their blinkered and flawed notions.

    There needs to be more opportunity to challenge these power-crazy leaders. But enough about the BBC's Strategy Review, the election debates clearly have room for improvement along the same lines.

 
 

This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

Previous
The BBC's Window of Creative Competition explained

Thursday 27 May 2010, 08:59

Next
The BBC North Recruitment drive continues

Friday 28 May 2010, 16:12

About this Blog

This blog explains what the BBC does and how it works. We link to some other blogs and online spaces inside and outside the corporation. The blog is edited by Jon Jacob.

Follow About the BBC on Twitter

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?

External links about the BBC

BBC Three online proposals set out as relaunch scheduled for autumn 2015 (Digital Spy)
"This is not moving a TV channel and putting it online. This is new. We are the first broadcaster in the world to propose something like this."

BBC Three to cut Don't Tell the Bride and other reality TV shows when channel moves online (Independent)

BBC theme park featuring Doctor Who and Top Gear set to open in 2020 (Telegraph)

JK Rowling's Cormoran Strike crime novel The Cuckoo's Calling will be turned into BBC series (Daily Mail)
"With the rich character of Cormoran Strike at their heart, these dramas will be event television across the world."

Yentob leads the BBC fightback: we're being smeared for exposing Fake Sheikh (Independent)

BBC Makes Unprecedented Counter-Attack To Sun Editorial Accusing It Of Left-Wing Bias (Huffington Post)

Serial podcast set to air on Radio 4 Extra (Radio Times)
"We know we already have tons of Serial listeners in the UK but we love that the BBC will help us reach many, many more than we ever could with podcast alone"

BBC iPlayer launches on Xbox One (Broadband TV News)

BBC ‘a great British company, not a government department’: Danny Cohen (Guardian)
"I ask you to stand by the BBC in the year ahead. Support it, make the case for it, speak up for it, celebrate its achievements and help us make sure we can keep offering such an extraordinary range of programmes for all audiences."

See Doctor Who, Miranda, more in BBC Christmas trailer (Digital Spy)

The BBC is right to point out failure on debt. Osborne is wrong to complain about it (The Spectator)

Chris Morris returns to airwaves with new sketch on BBC 6 Music on Sunday (Guardian)
"Blue Jam and On the Hour satirist’s first radio sketch in 15 years will be broadcast on Mary Anne Hobbs’ morning show"

BBC releases game maker kit for kids (Ariel)

BBC Music Sound of 2015 longlist revealed (Guardian)
"Solo artists such as James Bay, George The Poet and Raury make up most of this year’s list of musicians tipped for big things in 2015"

Why Gillian Anderson is the new Helen Mirren (Telegraph)

War and Peace to take over Radio 4: Ten-hour production of Tolstoy's novel to be broadcast on station on New Year's Day (Daily Mail)

Sherlock returns: BBC confirms special with picture of Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman back filming (Mirror)

The Reith Lectures explain why doctors fail (Telegraph)
"Dr Atul Gawande delivered an excellent first lecture on the fallibility of medicine, says Gillian Reynolds"

Nine-year-old Katie Morag star on winning BAFTA award and juggling TV series with school lessons (Scottish Daily Record)

Strictly Come Dancing 2014: Same-sex couple dance received positively (Metro)

Doctor Who, Andrew Scott and Sir Ian McKellen up for BBC Audio Drama Awards 2015 (Radio Times)
"Maxine Peake, Marcus Brigstocke and Toby Jones also scoop nominations for their work in audio drama"

Last updated Thursday 11 December 2014

Blogs from across the BBC

Selected by the About the BBC Blog team.

Making radio [BBC Outreach & Corporate Responsibilty]
Award-winning research [Media Action]
BBC Online Briefing Winter 2014: keynote [Internet]
Booking agents: how they can develop your act [BBC Introducing]
Introducing Emma Smith one of our new 2015 Fellows [BBC Performing Art Fund]


MatOf ThDay At 50: onic theme even has a banjo [TV]