Has the final whistle been blown on What Happened Next?

Thursday 11 April 2013, 16:09

Gareth Edwards Gareth Edwards Producer

Tagged with:

In recent weeks many viewers of A Question Of Sport have been commenting on Twitter and other sites that they miss the 'What Happened Next?' round and are wondering why it is no longer a regular feature in the programme. This blog is my way of trying to respond to those comments and explain why it has only appeared in a handful of shows over the past 12 months.

'What happened next?’ Barely a weekend goes by without a sporting correspondent somewhere in the UK referring to it in their commentary when a mistake or blooper takes place. It is equally common to hear it on the amateur sports fields of the country. It is certainly the case where I play club cricket when an easy catch is dropped. 

The famous round on A Question of Sport has been a crowd favourite since the early days of the programme back in the 1970s. To be perfectly honest when we look back at some of those early shows the What Happened Next? footage wasn't exactly side-splittingly humourous. Early examples include a Manchester United match when the teams saw Bobby Charlton frozen in time as he is about to send a cross over into the box...what happened next? Was there a streaker? Did the goalkeeper's shorts fall down? Did the referee cop one in the face? No to all those, the rather tepid answer was that Denis Law headed in a rather run of the mill goal. A more innocent time perhaps? 

Over the years the round developed and fast became a beacon of light-heartedness amid a sea of sporting trivia. During the ‘80s and ‘90s most viewers can remember Botham, Beaumont or McCoist coming up with all manner of possibilities to the outcome of the frozen sports footage. The sports involved became far more varied and the teams and people involved came from all four corners of the globe. I remember one of my first jobs as a researcher on the show (probably in late 1999) was to track down and find the footage from an international football match involving Hong Kong and Macao. I also remember the 2002 Commonwealth Games for some reason being a gold mine of sporting blunders.

However in recent years with the advent of 24-hour News along with YouTube, Twitter and other social media sites these incidents, no matter where in the world they come from, are all over the internet and television within minutes. Recently there was an interruption in a Swiss League football match where a rodent invaded the pitch and was chased around by the players before eventually biting one of them on the finger.

Pine Marten

Quite simply this is the kind of incident that What Happened Next? was made for. Within 24 hours of this game being played the video was a YouTube phenomenon, people's Twitter feeds were full of links to the story and the player involved had been interviewed on radio and television. The problem with using this footage in the quiz is once we have recorded a show there is normally a 3-4 week period before transmission, sometimes longer. By which stage the world and his wife will have seen the clip countless times, making our show look very dated.

Another problem is that some of the biggest Tweeters are sports people, none more so than our captain Matt Dawson. So the probability that they will have seen it, or retweeted it, by the time they are on the panel is high. I had already accepted that funnies from the Premier League, 6 Nations, Wimbledon or any of the major sporting events were no longer possibilities – their profile and coverage is simply too great. However when that sphere of exclusion starts to include Swiss football then our options do start to become very limited. 

As the Series Producer I am desperately keen to still try and include WHN? within the show whenever possible. Maybe we will have to dig further to find gems like this golf clip from the Women's European Tour

We are not throwing in the towel on What Happened Next? just yet.…

 

Gareth Edwards is Series Producer of A Question of Sport, the next episode is broadcast on Wednesday 17 April, on BBC One.

Tagged with:

Comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
 
 

This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

Previous
Sony Radio Academy Awards 2013 Nominations

Wednesday 10 April 2013, 15:19

Next
Why we're playing 'Ding Dong The Witch is Dead' on Radio 1's Sunday 14 April 2013 Chart Show

Friday 12 April 2013, 14:35

About this Blog

This blog explains what the BBC does and how it works. We link to some other blogs and online spaces inside and outside the corporation. The blog is edited by Jon Jacob.

Follow About the BBC on Twitter

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?

External links about the BBC

Future Media roles to move to Salford (Ariel)

Wimbledon final watched by 10 million (Guardian)
"Novak Djokovic victory over Roger Federer takes 54% share on BBC1, but no match for Andy Murray’s win last year"

TV News celebrates its 60th birthday (Ariel)

Doctor Who: Frank Cottrell Boyce is a genius, says Steven Moffat (Digital Spy)
"BBC One has confirmed that Frank Cottrell Boyce will script an episode of Doctor Who."

Danger Mouse remake will see some male characters returning as females (Guardian)
"CBBC’s Cheryl Taylor promises show ‘truthful to the essence of Danger Mouse’ but with fresh ideas"

BBC appoints Matthew Postgate as chief technology officer (Guardian)
"Current controller of research and development was part of the management team that created iPlayer and built mobile services"

Radio 5 Live: Presenters Richard Bacon, Victoria Derbyshire and Shelagh Fogarty among names leaving BBC radio station (Mirror)

Doctor Who trailer: take a Deep Breath, Capaldi fans (Guardian)
"A teaser for the 'feature-length' first episode of the new Doctor Who series has materialised, complete with Peter Capaldi, the Tardis in flames and a hint of menace"

Teenagers take over Scottish Thought for the Day (Ariel)

BBC increases digital radio coverage with Northern transmitters (Prolific North)

BBC to show off Commonwealth Games in 4K UHD (TechRadar)
"first ever event to be produced entirely over IP/internet networks - which the BBC is calling a 'major broadcasting milestone'"

BBC3 wins big at 2014 Broadcast Digital Awards (Broadcast)

Glastonbury 2014: how to watch it on TV (Daily Telegraph)
"Missed out on Glastonbury Festival tickets this year? Follow all the action from home using our BBC TV and Radio guide."

BBC experiments with virtual reality (Ariel)

BBC stages first world war rap battle (Guardian)

UK media in one-minute silence protest over jailing of al-Jazeera journalists (Guardian)
"Hundreds of reporters across BBC and other media organisations speak out against Egyptian government’s verdict"

Licence fee should be charged to iPlayer users, says acting chair of BBC Trust (Guardian)
"Diane Coyle, acting chair of the BBC Trust, says the BBC is 'less independent than it needs to be'"

Acting BBC Trust chair to apply to become Lord Patten’s replacement (Guardian)

BBC announces new comedy pilots (Chortle)
"the Comedy Feeds show serious commitment to finding the next best writers, directors and faces of British comedy"

After 25 years at the helm Jeremy Paxman presents his final Newsnight (Telegraph) 
"During his tenure, the 63-year-old earned a reputation as one of the most fearless and feared interviewers"

Sherlock and Downton Abbey are as good as Breaking Bad and Mad Men, says BBC boss (Independent)

Does Mary Berry Cooks mark a breakthrough for older women on TV?Does Mary Berry Cooks mark a breakthrough for older women on TV? (Guardian)"What results is an unapologetically old-fashioned TV show with a presenter who makes no attempt to disguise when she was born"

Last updated Tuesday 8 July 2014

Blogs from across the BBC

Selected by the About the BBC Blog team.

The Events - Q&A with writer David Greig [Writersroom]
Cooking with Cat: banana yoghurt ice lollies and savoury pastry tart [CBeebies Grown Ups]
Five ways local media can help itself #localjournalism [Academy]
Responsive design in data and tables [Internet]
Preview Tactics [Kermode Uncut]

Connected Red Button: a first look at the new service on Smart TVs [Internet]