Satellite Shuffling: reducing BBC Red Button and expanding BBC One HD

Director, BBC Distribution

Just as the Paralympics kicked off at the start of September I wrote about a modification to our HD satellite transponder that I can happily report went ahead successfully as planned on 27 September 2012. This increased the capacity available to us and was the first of a number of modifications we are making to our satellite transmissions over the coming months to enable us to implement two key changes to our service line-up:

  1. In the middle of October we will be reducing the number of BBC Red Button video streams on satellite (and cable) to one. This will mean we close our ‘DSat7’ transponder (Astra 2A tp 13).
  2. Over the next few months we will be launching BBC One HD for the nations of Northern Ireland, Wales and Scotland. They will each be available on terrestrial, satellite and cable platforms. In order to carry these services on satellite we’ll be opening a new transponder (Astra 1N tp 61) which we will be referring to as DSat8.


These changes will affect different people in different ways, and I know from reading your responses to my previous blogs that some of you take issue with the changes, so I wanted to explain the thinking behind the decisions as well as what will be happening from a technical standpoint.

1. BBC Red Button video streams

In November 2010, the BBC Trust published its review of the BBC Red Button and challenged the BBC Executive “to reduce its distribution costs by providing a more consistent level of service across different digital TV platforms”. Accordingly, the BBC’s Delivering Quality First proposals in October 2011 set out a plan to reduce the number of BBC Red Button video streams on satellite and cable from five to one and save the costs of one transponder.

I know that the BBC Red Button service as a whole is very appreciated and used by a wide section of the population, who value the ease of access to text and video at the press of a button. And the BBC is committed to maintaining a vibrant and popular red button service. We have exciting future plans for the BBC Red Button, as my colleague Tom Williams explains on the BBC Internet blog.

What’s happening when?

Turning to the technical changes involved, as I’m sure you can imagine, closing a transponder is not as simple as flicking a switch. There are a number of stages we’ll be working through in the next few weeks. Most of them should be invisible to you but there are a couple of dates in particular to note.

Step 1: Move the TV services

The one remaining BBC Red Button service will move from DSat7 to DSat1 (Astra 1N tp 45) but in order to make this fit and optimise how our more and less capacity-hungry channels are arranged, we need to shuffle some of our TV services around. So in the early hours of 12 October 2012:

• BBC Three / CBBC (DSat1) and BBC News (DSat 2) will move to DSat6 (Astra 1N tp 48)

• BBC ALBA and BBC One North East & Cumbria will both move from DSat6 to DSat2 (Astra 1N tp 47)

• BBC Four / CBeebies (DSat2) and BBC Red Button stream 1 (DSat7) will move to DSat1

Step 2: Move the radio services

On 15 October 2012 we will move our radio services on the Sky platform from DSat2 and DSat7 to be more evenly spread across DSat2 and DSat5 (Astra 1N tp 46). On the 16 October 2012 these changes will take effect on Freesat and Virgin Media. As each of the radio services moves there will be a small outage of a couple of minutes.

This will also mean that our radio services move from a European beam to a UK spot beam as DSat7 is the last of our European beam transponders. We use a UK beam for our TV services, so the radio services will be as available in the UK as our TV services. But it does mean that the radio services will no longer be receivable across much of mainland Europe. I’ve no doubt that some readers of this blog will be disappointed by this news. But I’m afraid European-beam transponders are not cost effective for us. We broadcast our services for UK audiences “in the clear” or unencrypted (which is what makes Freesat possible) and so for rights reasons we are limited in terms of the services that we are able to broadcast on a European beam. The BBC’s radio station for listeners outside the UK is the BBC World Service, and it is widely available throughout the world. In Europe you can receive the World Service in many different ways including on satellite from Eutelsat Hot Bird 8 at 13° East. It’s also available online 24 hours a day via the listen live link from the BBC World Service homepage.

On 15 October 2012 we will also stop using the four other BBC Red Button streams.

Step 3: Close the transponder

DSat7 will then close at the end of October.

How will this affect me?

Full details of the new line-up will be published on our reception advice page from 12 October 2012.

The change will mean different things to different people:

• If you watch TV or listen to radio using Freeview or Virgin Media, you will not be affected.

• If you have Sky, you should not notice the change and shouldn’t have to do anything. If you do have an issue receiving any of our channels after these dates, you can try unplugging your Sky set top box, waiting 30 seconds and plugging it back in again. If that doesn’t resolve your problem it’s best to contact Sky on 08442 411 653.

• If you have Freesat you may need to put your digital box or TV into standby for 30 seconds and then switch it back on again. If the channels are still unavailable then carry out a 'Freesat channel retune'. Full instructions can be found in the manual for your digital TV or box. Further help with retuning can be found at www.freesat.co.uk or by calling the Freesat customer support team on 08450 990 990.

• If you have any other kind of satellite receiver that can currently receive our services you’ll need to either get it to retune or configure it manually using the details on our reception advice page. Please consult the manual for more information.

As well as briefing Sky and Freesat, we have contacted satellite and aerial installer trade associations – the CAI (Confederation of Aerial Industries) and the RDI (Registered Digital Installers) – providing them with information with which to brief their members in case anyone experiencing a problem contacts an installer rather than their platform operator. We have also put information about this change on BBC Red Button page 998 and it will be in the Radio Times because we know not everyone has access to the internet.

2. BBC One HD for the nations

We will be launching BBC One HD for Northern Ireland, Wales and Scotland over the next few months. I’ll update you with exact dates when we have them confirmed. We are launching them across all of our broadcast platforms so the channels will be available subscription-free on Sky HD, Freeview HD, Virgin Media and Freesat HD at the same position in the EPG where BBC One HD is currently found. As with our other nations and regional channels on satellite, the nations HD services won’t carry audio description. So we will be listing the current version of BBC One HD in the 900s on Sky HD and Freesat HD so that viewers in Northern Ireland, Wales and Scotland will still be able to access audio description.

If you live in Northern Ireland, Wales or Scotland, you should find that the service appears automatically from launch if you have an HD satellite or cable service. If you have Freeview HD, you may well find that your TV or set-top-box retunes itself to pick up the channel. If not, you will need to do a re-tune after the new service has launched. Help with this can be found on tvretune.co.uk. Whichever platform you use, if you have scheduled recordings on BBC One HD, please check them after your new national HD service launches to make sure you don’t miss any episodes of your favourite programmes.

When I mentioned in my previous blog that preparations for the launch of these services were underway, a number of readers posted comments querying why the BBC has chosen to launch BBC One HD for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland instead other BBC TV channels in HD. So I thought I’d include an explanation of that in this main post. At its heart, it comes down to striking a balance between the different technical and cost considerations on DTT compared with satellite.

• Technical: On DTT, we are constrained in terms of the space available to launch services in HD, whereas on satellite, the capacity is there…at a price.

• Cost: On satellite, it costs essentially the same to launch an HD service whether it is a pan-UK TV channel, like BBC Three or BBC Four, or a national or regional variant of BBC One HD. However, on DTT, it is somewhat cheaper to launch a national or regional variant, as we tailor the network in that part of the UK to point to the new feed.

So with limited DTT spectrum and limited funds, our expansion of HD has focused on the nations versions of BBC One HD.

One reader pointed out that there are a number of English regions that have larger populations than the nations, and asked why they weren’t prioritised. Population size is one factor we have borne in mind. However, another key factor is the length of time that the BBC One schedule in that part of the UK is different from a “network” feed. For English regions, this time is mostly made up by the regional news bulletins. However, in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, the schedule can vary significantly from network particularly in peak time. So this launch of the HD services for the nations will help to make BBC One HD more relevant to its viewers in the nations and more true to the SD service the BBC broadcasts.

One other reader suggested BBC Two HD as a priority, and I’m pleased to confirm that plans announced earlier this year to convert BBC HD into BBC Two HD are progressing towards completion next year.

Finally, some readers were curious to know how we planned to fit BBC HD and four versions of BBC One HD into a single transponder without messing up picture quality. The answer is that we’re not. We have bought a new DVB-S2 transponder (DSat8) alongside the existing DSat4. Each of these transponders will carry two versions of BBC One HD and DSat4 will also carry BBC HD, as it does now. (We are evaluating options for the spare capacity on DSat8.) My esteemed colleagues in BBC Research & Development have put a great deal of painstaking work into the configurations of these two transponders to try to match the picture quality of each version of BBC One HD to the one we have at the moment, and maintain BBC HD’s picture quality, for which I am very grateful.

So we have a busy autumn ahead of us in BBC Distribution, helping to deliver the above transitions. I hope your experience of these changes will be a smooth one and that this post has given you a clearer picture of the rationale and work behind them.

Alix Pryde is Director, BBC Distribution

Red Button Development Editor Tom Williams has also written about changes to Red Button on the BBC Internet Blog.

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments.

  • Comment number 25. Posted by Kai

    on 15 Oct 2012 19:24

    Good News: With a exactly pointed dish you should still be able to receive all of the transponders at least in France, BeNeLux, Switzerland and most of Germany.
    I'm in the middle of Germany and everything is still working fine with a 90cm dish and surprisingly even on my 45cm camping dish (TechniSat DigiDish 45).
    Bad News: In early 2013 BBC's Channels are supposed to move to Astra 2F, with a even smaller spotbeam, making it very hard to receive outside the UK.

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 25: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 25: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 24. Posted by DJ205

    on 15 Oct 2012 17:16

    I'm interested to find out if the closure of BBC HD means the end of 3D broadcasting by the BBC for the time being. Whenever this has been done before (Strictly final, Wimbledon, Olympics) it was simualcast in 3D on BBC HD. Or will BBC Two HD carry the 3D stream whilst SD BBC Two carries on as normal?

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 24: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 24: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 23. Posted by ChazzSp

    on 13 Oct 2012 22:29

    Had a problem scanning in the new 8PSK service? I couldn't get it on my Skyline HD sat rcvr until I tried a lower SR of 22995

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 23: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 23: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 22. Posted by castalla

    on 8 Oct 2012 18:36

    While these moves may not technically breach the EU directive on Television Without Frontiers since they are not expressly devised to block cross-border reception, they surely break the spirit and intent of the Directive.

    An absolute disgrace, but then BBC World tv shows adverts for Rolex, etc. so I'm not surprised the commercial barbarians are ruling the roost at the old Beeb.

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 22: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 22: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 21. Posted by tony ormsby

    on 8 Oct 2012 00:56

    One of the things that make Freesat so much better than freevieu has been the five red button feeds. These show up on (on other channel menu) as five channels.

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 21: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 21: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 20. Posted by neil201

    on 7 Oct 2012 22:14

    Louis, sorry to say this so bluntly but the BBC's domestic services are for us UK residents who support the corporation in paying a licence fee. If you choose to live in France then that's your issue in terms of loss of UK PSB radio or TV. I recommend you listen to the French radio networks if you speak French, alternatively BBC World Service radio. If you miss things like this offered in the UK you could always move back to Norfolk!

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 20: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 20: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 19. Posted by louis norman Wells

    on 7 Oct 2012 16:38

    I certainly am Louis Norman Wells!.A Britsh citizen born and brought up in Norfolk.Reached my 87th birthday a week ago,and have lved in France as a pensioner for the last 24 years,moving here on retirement for health and economic reasons,like so many others of my generation.The whole of my career was spent in the Radio and Electronics Industry,so I am well able to understand the technicalities behind the BBC,s decisions. It would be more fitting for the BBC to make its economies elsewhere,salaries for instance, than in the information service it has furnished nationally and to the rest of the World for many generations. A service which is still highly regarded for its truth and lack of partiality

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 19: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 19: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 18. Posted by louis norman Wells

    on 7 Oct 2012 16:17

    To the tens of thousands of UK citizens living on the Continent the decision to drastically reduce the Radio Channel Footprint will be a bodyblow.
    The Overseas Service is of little value to us,who wish to remain in touch with events locally and in the UK generally ,and to listen to our favourite prorammes . Do we no longer exist ?
    For many of us the Radio channels are more important than the TV,whose Programmes frequently lack interest to we of advancing years!

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 18: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 18: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 17. Posted by TelevisionUser

    on 5 Oct 2012 19:57

    I really don't care to be patronised and deceived by anyone over the loss of the extra satellite Red Button services - this was purely and simply a crude cost cutting measure and it's about time that the BBC were honest with viewers about this unfortunate move. I do appreciate that the ultimate architect of the current situation was the squalid and compromised Murdoch poodle that was Culture Secretary Hunt but that's still no excuse for the BBC to use mendacious spin about this matter.

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 17: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 17: 0
    Loading…
  • Comment number 16. Posted by ropies

    on 5 Oct 2012 18:33

    An interesting blog.

    I'm disappointed that now we're into the promised land of astra 1N (finally) that the BBC has chosen to develop the nations variants of BBC1 in HD only at the moment. I was really hoping that not only would you do this, but there would be a proper roadmap for getting BBC2/3/4/News into HD between 2012 and 2015. BBC2 by the end of 2013 seems a bit slow, but at least it is coming. I can only hope that as in the past the BBC will change it's mind at some appropriate time.

    Platform neutrality seems an outdated policy. The numbers of HD households with freesat/sky/cable is so high now even I've stopped reading what the numbers are! It could be towards the end of this decade or even into the next before a second mux on freeview is made into DVB-S2 and HD channels put on it. Is it a wise policy when by this time ITV2/3/4 HD will probably be on virgin media and possibly even on freesat by that time as well as other PSB channels?

    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of positive ratings for comment 16: 0
    • This entry is now closed for comments. Number of negative ratings for comment 16: 0
    Loading…
More comments