BBC HomeExplore the BBC

26 December 2009
Accessibility help
Text only

BBC Homepage

Local BBC Sites

Neighbouring Sites

Related BBC Sites


Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Community features

You are in: Birmingham > Your Community > Community features > The Race debate

The Race debate

The Race debate

The Race debate

Watch a powerful thought provoking documentary made by local filmmakers. It explores the issues of race and immigration in Birmingham and the rise of the BNP. Birmingham's leading community figures express their views in a lively debate.

Birmingham's communities

Birmingham's community

For the first time in Birmingham's history the British National Party gained a seat on the city council in May 2006. This once again sparked a debate on race and immigration in the city.

Approximately 29.6% of people living in Birmingham are now from a non-white background. That percentage is increasing with a prediction of Birmingham becoming the first city in the UK to become majority ethnic.

‘The Race’ debate documentary

The Race is a powerful thought provoking documentary made by two local filmmakers.

Filmmaker Ravi Singh (Burnt Out Productions)  explains: "I was inspired to make this film because I was intrigued why so many people were drifting towards the BNP when it came to voting at election time.

May 2006 local elections

May 2006 local elections

"I then wanted to investigate further whether the population of Birmingham could define what it was to be British and whether they were proud to be British."

Filmmaker Mark Corden (Perpetual Motion) adds: "I have a background in documentary film-making and a keen interest in politics.  Hearing about the election of a BNP candidate to the Birmingham council galvenised me into investigating this unprecedented event. 

"I wanted to know what the lay of the land was in Birmingham regarding ethnicity, immigration, and the nature of Britishness."

Racism or pride?

The documentary explores the controversial issues of race, immigration and community cohesion in the city since the BNP council seat gain in Birmingham.

Sharon Ebanks, ex BNP councillor

Sharon Ebanks - New Nationalist Party Chairman

It also features an exclusive interview with councillor Sharon Ebanks whose views on race and immigration in the UK have been viewed by many as being racist.

Sharon’s response to her critics is: “The politics in this country is failing the British person, it doesn’t address their needs at a grass roots level. I can relate to them fully and I do genuinely care."

The debate

In September 2006 Sharon was expelled from the party due to reasons that have yet to be explained. She moved on to set up the New Nationalist Party (NNP).

Opinion on the street

Opinion on the street

The documentary also includes expressed views from Kahild Mahmood (Perry Barr Labour MP), Bishop Joe Aldred (Birmingham Churches Together), Rabbi Leonard Tann (Birmingham Hebrew Congregation), Dr Mohammed Naseem (Chairman of Birmingham Central Mosque) and views from members of the public.

Watch 'The Race'

Watch The Race documentary below split into topical sections and join in the debate on our messageboard.

Kingstanding and the BNP

In the May 2006 local elections BNP Councillor Sharon Ebanks was declared the winner for the Kingstanding ward which sparked controversy on the city’s council.

(Quotes from the film...)

Bishop Joe Aldred (Birmingham Churches Together): “Approximately 30,000 people in England voted for the BNP in the May 2006 elections which is quite startling. We have to try and engage in a dialogue with the party and understand their reasoning."

Bishop Joe Aldred

Bishop Joe Aldred - Birmingham Churches Together

Khalid Mahmood (Perry Barr Labour MP): “The area of Kingstanding has its issues and they need to be addressed.”

Sharon Ebanks: “The majority of people living in Kingstanding are British people so we are able to understand their situations and relate to them fully.”

Watch The Race (Part 1) – Kingstanding and the BNP

What is Britishness?

What does it now mean to be British?

(Quotes from the film...)

Kahlid Mahmood: “It’s about people living in a society and appreciating the lifestyle within the laws and rights of this nation.”

Sharon Ebanks: “British people are becoming extinct.

Opinion on the Street

"I'm proud to be British"

"We have a wonderful history and culture. We’ve given a lot to this world and I think we still have a lot to give if we are provided with the correct education and correct environment to thrive in, where we can have our own communities that aren’t fractured by people from the outside."

Opinion on the street: “My definition of Britishness is to uphold the law and abide by the rules of the country. My parents came into this country and worked really hard. I’m proud to be British.”

Dr Mohammed Naseem (Chairman of Birmingham Central Mosque): “We are all contributing to the British culture.”

Watch The Race (Part 2) - What is Britishness?

Race and Immigration

(Quotes from the film...)

Sharon Ebanks: “ I‘m absolutely against immigration into this country as it stands today. It causes fractures within communities and it’s affecting the job market and the education of our British children."

Siobhan Harper-Nunes

Siobhan Harper-Nunes - Shakti-gar regeneration

Bishop Joe Aldred: “There are people around the world under persecution and are suffering economically, these are the main reasons why people are driven to move around the world."

Siobhan Harper Nunes: “In Birmingham there’s a beautiful variety of cultures. People form tight groups when they come into this country because they are afraid of racism and the reaction on the community they will be joining."

Watch The Race ( Part 3 )  -  Race and Immigration in Birmingham

Multiculturalism

(Quotes from the film...)

How has multiculturalism affected the social and political fabric of British society?

Kahlid Mahmood - Labour MP Perry Barr

Kahlid Mahmood - Labour MP Perry Barr

Kahlid Mahmood: “Multiculturalism is people being able to be a part of the society in this country but at the same time keeping their cultural heritage and sharing the best practice of that in our communities and society.”

Rabbi Leonard Tann (Birmingham Hebrew Congregation): “Multiculturalism works if people are brought together, talk together and understand each other on an equal basis."

Opinion on the street: “We have so many people from different countries, backgrounds and faiths here. Everyone is coming together and uniting within the UK.”

Watch The Race ( Part 4 )  -  Multiculturalism

Final thoughts

(Quotes from the film...)

Sharon Ebanks: "Enoch Powell’s description of immigration and what it would do in our communities has absolutely come to pass.

Rabbi Leonard Tann

Rabbi Leonard Tann- Birmingham Hebrew Congregation

"People are coming into this country from Iraq, Kurdistan, Somalia, Ethiopia etc… and they are altering the face of this country. They are not wanting to share in our practices that we have been comfortable with for hundreds of years.

"They are coming in and ground rules are being laid down especially for them which enable segregation and that’s extremely dangerous."

Rabbi Leonard Tann: "We live in a modern world where people are moving around to find better lives for themselves. The concept of we can 'protect our own little island' is nonsense."

Watch The Race (Part 5) – Final thoughts

Have your say

What are your thoughts on the views expressed in ‘The Race’ documentary? Join the debate on our message board.

(NB. The Race was filmed and produced by Birmingham based film production companies Burned Out and Perpetual Motion)

last updated: 06/07/07

You are in: Birmingham > Your Community > Community features > The Race debate



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy