BBC HomeExplore the BBC

23 December 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
BerkshireBerkshire

BBC Homepage
England
»BBC Local
Berkshire
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Berkshire

Hampshire
London
Oxford
Wiltshire

Related BBC Sites

England
 

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Previews and features

Shorty
Shorty

Screwed up at Screwball

By Linda Serck
Plug 'n' Play's monthly musical melee Screwball Cabaret hosted Reading Fringe Festival's launch party on Thursday 17 August. With the mix of music BBC Berkshire heard that night, should we really be celebrating?

WHO PLAYED?

  • Three Litre
  • The Palestinians
  • Through Snowy Static
  • The Hundred Handed
  • Headliners: Shorty



    Plug 'n' Play

    Milford Road

    Reading

    Thursday 17 August

It's the launch of the Reading Fringe Festival. It's at the seventies kitsch Plug 'n' Play studios. It's got five bands and even better, it's got an invisible Dalek as compere.

So why weren't there more of you there?

Never mind, you were probably washing your hair or organising your sock drawer eh. Well, don't be overly downhearted you missed it.

Three Litre

Three Litre played two sets-worth of comedy lyrics behind acoustic guitar, snare drum and cowbell.

"Shorty are one of the best bands I've heard live all year."

The sound was pretty appalling, not least because bands in the practice rooms were thrashing out far louder songs - a case of over-booking?

Three Litre works best if you've never heard them before - you can laugh incredulously at the wit and rhyming panache of frontman Graham Burgess. The now Kent resident certainly delighted headliners Shorty, who were patiently waiting in the wings.

Three Litre definitely need to stay electric however, not even a mini keyboard and toy glockenspiel could add any sweetness.

The Palestinians

What's so good about Screwball Cabaret is that they thrive on the eclectic mix of music. So from pub rock we shuffle over to the main hall for some Sex Pistols-era punk from The Palestinians.

The Palestinians
The Palestinians

They come dressed as hooded monks but appear like the grim reaper collective. With two out the five dressed in a hoodie and T-shirt however, the medieval doom effect falls somewhat flat.

And thank heavens for ASBOs, the war on Iraq and general youth disillusionment, as otherwise what would this ragbag of sweaty men sing about?

That they relish the confrontational is inherent in their name, and the anarchic fuzz sounds snarlingly warm, but, for example, their Welcome To England lyrics is a blatant smash 'n' grab of The Clash's This Is England.

Political rants and lyrical anger can so easily become tiresome when done as a carbon copy of a bygone era. Inject something fresh and contemporary and they'll be on to something.

Through Snowy Static

Through Snowy Static
Through Snowy Static

Through Snowy Static are thankfully a highlight of the evening. The duo, only 18 and 20, are visibly nervous and again the muffled roar from a band in the practice room ruins the attention that these two command.

Named after a Bright Eyes lyric and world-weary beyond their years, the elfish lad certainly uses Conor Oberst as a poetic influence.

The girl's sugary voice sounds like Stars' Amy Milian as they float through sweet-sounding hushed melodies, ever so simple and achingly heart-wrenching.

Nerves get the better of them and they forget lyrics a few times, but even so this band are a leading light whose glow is destined to shine on many.

The Hundred Handed

The Hundred Handed are plain odd. The singer looks like a twisted cross between a young bryl-creamed Bryan Ferry and Jake Shears of Scissor Sisters.

Thinking about it, the Londoners' late-night wail and nascent disco beat is of a similar hybrid. It's glam that's got ugly and annoyed.

They've brought their number one fan along tonight, the only one who thrusts his hips to and fro for the whole set. He's the only one who wants to.

The bassist is clearly on something mind-altering and he thinks it looks good. It doesn't. Him and an equally tall blond mooch about like some Aryan Cheech and Chong. Very funny. Not.

Shorty

Shorty
Shorty

The night is saved by seven-piece headliners Shorty.

Mixing heavy rock, funk, soul and rap, they're a British version of Holland's Urban Dance Squad, with a kick-ass scratch DJ. They send the few stragglers left, and myself, into a frenzy. In fact, Shorty are one of the best bands I've heard live all year.

The singers/rappers/MCers, (two male, one sassy female) engage in Jurassic 5-style tag-team delivery and play off each other like mime-artists in a light-hearted musical. Meanwhile we all crunch down and stomp to the thick beats and colossal riffs.

I've never seen a band enjoy themselves and smile so much. And it's infectious. Catch them live and leave uplifted.
 

last updated: 01/12/06
 
Have Your Say
Your name: 
Your comment: 
 
The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

dan lomas
they are a rubbish band, they can't sing a bloody note

Mudlark
Well, journalists have a responsibility to report acurately, and from what I hear, this is a kind report of the night.

Dan Lomas
Linda is lovely. These comments are pathetic. I was actually so embarrased reading them. As a band you should be able to take criticism and gain something positive from it, not argue against it with childish comments for all to see. Rookies!

Linda BBC Berkshire
One of the things I expect from putting my neck out and being honest in my opinions is that I people will disagree with me and whizz over veiled insults or even direct insults at me. "You don't understand" is a childish remark, my kids I'm sure will love Shorty but not the others, having a pop at my age is just ridiculous, "lazy journalism" - I believe I was the only journalist who bothered to show up? AMy friends did NOT get in for free - I took my brother along as my 'plus one', which is standard.

Rob from Screwball
Hillarious comments! (if a bit rude) Personally, I enjoyed it. It's a shame that Linda didn't but I guess it's just not her thing. She may not understand it but her kids will love it! Still, even if the bands weren't to her taste her and her friends who got in for free stayed all night and seemed to be smiling most of the time. Maybe she was writing the review in her head at the time? :op

austin
hmmm....whilst i don't mind getting a stinker of a review (in fact its pretty refreshing given the usual back-slapping around in reading), comparing us to the Pistols and the Clash is pretty lazy journalistically, especially as we sound like neither. Plus our song 'Welcome to England" has virtually nothing in common lyrically with "This is England", though why we would rip off a dreadful 1985 Clash song is a mystery to me. Lastly, how could you even hear the lyrics over the din we make?.... Surely writing about modern issues is far more interesting than the dreadful meaningless lyrics most bands write? Anyway, I'm pleased to see the review is critical and has the chutzpah to give an opinion

gilmour
Through Snowy Static and Three Litre Were both really enjoyable. And Shorty took the roof off - they really were excellent. But I have to agree with Linda, Hundred Handed were not good at all, I'll stop before I get to rude!

Simon
I thought Shorty were brilliant. I saw the write-up beforehand and wasn't sure it'd be me thing, but they were stomping. Made my night. Three Litre were hilarious and the others weren't that bad.

Dr Karl
The person who put this show on must have suffered a severe financial beating?

Jilm
Since the reviewer seems intent on making everything personal I think it is worth mentioning that she looks like a male to female transexual who chose the Zoe Ball face from the catalogue but could not afford the jaw reshaping operation

brizz
good luck with being 30 and writing indie reviews for BBC berks

Billy
Best.Review.Ever.

ghostman
Oh dear. Reviewer obviously on the blob.

Merve
A no-content, wishy-washy article. Overly flowery descriptions, with a bias to being personal and nasty against the bands. I wish the writer would write about the facts, rather than express her narrow minded, opinionated descriptions of the event.

I was there
I thought Hundred Handed were cool. I liked the bass player - he was well into it. Whats wrong with that?

SEE ALSO
home
HOME
email
EMAIL
print
PRINT
Go to the top of the page
TOP
SITE CONTENTS
SEE ALSO




About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy