BBC HomeExplore the BBC
Just to let you know, we're no longer updating this site. More information here

10 July 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
Documentaries BBC Four

BBC Homepage
BBC Television
Get BBC Four
FAQ

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
  John Hrankowski  

DEAD IN THE WATER

INTERVIEW

USS Liberty Crew Member

JOHN HRANKOWSKI

 
 

BBC Four: If it was not accidental, are there any particular theories you find most compelling as to why the Liberty was attacked?
JH: For the life of me I don't know. I don't think any of our guys do. The Israelis have got to tell us. There's a lot our government can tell us too. For our government to tell their planes to abandon us - evidently they had to have known something too. We know that there are still a lot of top secret classified papers from the National Security Agency and other organisations in the States. Hopefully those will hold the answers. I don't know what was on [President] Johnson's mind. I have no idea if he was talking to Israelis. That's why we need an investigation. We need to pull all the papers together.

BBC Four: Do the people from the Johnson administration deny that they recalled the flights?
JH: They don't deny it. They won't talk about it. [Johnson's Secretary of Defence] Robert McNamara, who was part of the cover-up, recalled two of the planes. He conveniently says he doesn't remember. Other times he says, "I don't know" and other times he says "I'm not going to talk about it." He knows something - he knows an awful lot. President Johnson - he had to have known at the time and there are still other people around that know why this happened. There are laws against abandoning someone under fire and that's exactly what McNamara and the Johnson administration did. We were under attack for nearly two hours. For the first nine minutes they didn't know but after that they did not send help. Not that we didn't ask. We asked for help.

BBC Four: What sort of campaigning work are you and the other survivors doing to get people to look into this again?
JH: We're at it every day. We write our letters, we talk to people, we tell our story, we tell them to write to Congress and ask for a congressional investigation.

BBC Four: Do you have any support in Congress?
JH: Within the last couple of months there have been three congressmen who are aware of the situation. Of course I'm not going to tell you who they are but for the first time in all these years there is some interest there.

Read Admiral Shlomo Erell's version of events from an Israeli perspective

Back to the Dead in the Water homepage

 
 
ADMIRAL SHLOMO ERELL
The former head of the Israeli navy tells his side of the story
  Adm. Shlomo Erell

Divers investigate the torpedo wound to the USS Liberty
Divers investigate the torpedo wound to the USS Liberty

Further Links

USS Liberty
Comprehensive site run by two survivors with images and documents

USS Liberty
Another site, with info on the Dead in the Water video

Attack on the USS Liberty
Well-presented academic account of the conflicting arguments

USS Liberty Photo Album
Photos from the 60s and the crew's recent reunions

The Six-Day War
Overview from the American-Israeli Co-operative Enterprise

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites
         
 
 
  top^  


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy