BBC HomeExplore the BBC
Just to let you know, we're no longer updating this site. More information here


Accessibility help
Text only
BBC Homepage
BBC Music
404 Not Found

Not Found

The requested URL /cgi-perl/whatson/search/advance_search.cgi was not found on this server.

Listen Live RealPlayer


Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
6 Music is also available on DAB Digital Radio and Digital TV
Listen Live Win Media
The Great Debate
Which is the greatest Scottish band of all time?
The football team might be rubbish nowadays, but if rock’n’roll had its own Home Internationals, then Scotland would have been runaway 2004 champions.

Skids
The way Franz Ferdinand, Belle & Sebastian, Sons And Daughters and adopted Scots Snow Patrol have gone down better than an Arbroath smokie in the last 12 months was a timely reminder of how much more interesting the scene north of the border can be.

After all, while more celebrated cities like Liverpool and Manchester have essentially been producing the same group over and over again in recent years, all four hail from the same metropolis (Glasgow) yet sound nothing like each other.

It’s hardly a one-off, either. Over the years, Scottish rock has thrown up some of Britain’s most consistently inventive rock’n’roll bands.

Maybe it’s the distance from the music biz’s evil epicentre (ie London), maybe it’s something in the water, but whether it’s snarling rock animals like The Jesus And Mary Chain or sleek mainstream pop dolphins like Altered Images, no one rocks like the Scots rock.

The big question, of course, is which Scottish band is actually the best? Scottish listings mag The List is currently running a poll to find out, the results of which will be known next week, but we thought we’d get in early (and help cure that Hogmanay hangover) by asking you, the 6 Music massive, for your considered opinion?

So, Orange Juice or The Skids? The Pastels or Primal Scream? Mogwai or The Beta Band? Travis or Simple Minds? Idlewild or Aztec Camera? The Rezillos or The Delgados? Big Country or the Bay City Rollers? Send us your nominations now.

Just don’t get Berti Vogts to manage them …

Mark Sutherland

Disclaimer:The BBC will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published. The BBC reserves the right to edit comments that are published.

Comments so far

Kirsten, Toronto, Canada
Kevin McDermott Orchestra. Most underrated, but they're awesome.

Steve - London
SAHB - not just the greatest Scottish band of all time, but the greatest band of all time...full stop !

Borek Baloun,Karlovy Vary,Czech Republic
I love scottish landscape,scottish football,scottish castles,scottish villages and scottish music.I´m 39 and this is my modest opinion: 1. Big Country 2. Runrig 3.Simple Minds 4. Deacon Blue 5. Waterboys.Bye,Scotland forever.

frank ,skelmersdale lancs
only one contender folks,sahb.no contest

john mANCHESTER
SAHB the best ever

Alex Lowe, East Kilbride
Kevin McDermott Orchestra - one of the most under rated bands ever to come out of Glasgow. Mother Nature's Kitchen is a masterpiece

Jimmy Jazz Fife
The Skids, Scotland's answer to The Clash

Contact Us

Email The Music Week
Text on 64046
(Network charges apply)

Get the podcast

Download or subscribe to this programme's podcast

PodcastHelp

Listen Again

The Streets, the latest on Michael Jackson, and where music meets advertising

Lamacq's Musings

Steve Lamacq What's on Steve's mind?
19x12 comment boards orangeRead Lamacq's blog


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy