Tony Livesey

22:30 - 01:00

We discussed

What is Britain's most dangerous drug?

29/10/2009

Woman smoking

Ecstasy, LSD and cannabis are less harmful than alcohol and cigarettes, according to the Government's most senior drugs adviser.

Professor David Nutt wants a new 'index of harm' that'll highlight the relative dangers of various substances. He says alcohol should rank fifth, behind cocaine, heroin, barbiturates and methadone, while tobacco should rank ninth, ahead of cannabis, LSD and Ecstasy.

Do you agree with Professor Nutt? Is alcohol more harmful than cannabis, LSD and Ecstasy? Which drug has caused you the most harm? What do you think is Britain's most dangerous drug?

The comments below are archived from 5 live Connect which runs live between 9-10am during the Breakfast Phone-in each weekday morning. Find out more about 5 live Connect here.

You can download the Breakfast Phone-in podcast here.

Your comments

  • Show:
 

08:53

How can cannabis be less harmful than tobacco when the tobacco of a filter cig is used in the joint to smoke the cannabis, less the filter? Hugh in glasgow.

08:53

Good morning, and welcome to 5 live Now.

08:54

Why pay for researchers to provide scientific evidence if we choose to veto it based on media trends and taboos? Evidence shows alcohol, heroine, crack a nd tobacco are all much more highly addictive and fatal drugs than either ecstasy mdma or cannabis.

08:54

An alcoholic has a devastating effect on all close family members .Go to any Al anon meeting to see the suffering of family and friends Margaret

08:57

I work as a bed manager in a busy district hospital at least one third ofall admissions are alcohol abuse related another third are due to smoking relat ed illnesses so therefore i do feel that alxohol is a very dangerous drug affecting our society as a whole casualty depts are full of drunks and poli ce trying to control their abusive behaviour or staff caring for their victims and taking up very precious much needed hospital beds and scarce resources

08:57

Can't say my name but i've been a recreational drug user for nearly 17 years, i hold a good job, the only drug that has ever created hassle is alcohol, thats the worst drug. S.

08:58

Most dangerous drug currently, alcohol. Most potential to damge society in the future, cannabis. If you buy a lettuce from the supermarket it will effectively be clean. Cannabis grown in a forced environment, pesticides, fungicides and fertilisers remain in the plant and are then heated and inhaled. Thisis the cause of the future problems, this cocktail is what is causing the steep increase in cannabis induced psychosis that is a massive problem galloping over the horizon toward us. Trev. Cornwall.

08:58

Religion the most dangerous drug

08:59

A persons opinion of britains most dangerous drug can only be based on their own experience. My wife comes from a family of 4. Mum dad little brother and her. At 34 years of age she is the only one left. Mum 1989 Kestrel super strength. Dad 2005 vodka. Brother march this year white star. All legal. It was there MISUSE of booze that killed them. Our USE of illegal drugs however has left us in rare health. We need a total re evaluation of the current laws w ith the focus as it should be on our health and safety. Not on criminalisation and misinformation. Regards. Ali in durham

09:00

Interesting debate lately: sitting over dinner with some friends discussing whether or not to send our children to private school, one of the comments ba ck during the discussion was:- it's just a better class of drugs at private school! Hmmm. Mal of the high peak.

09:00

Alcohol can be fine. I have always liked a drink - a lot when i was in my twenties and a bit over the many years since. I have been drunk once or twice b ut NEVER been violent or destructive. I have never gone out to get drunk. I have never taken drugs, possibly because I don't want to get stoned either. The mindset of youth now, is to get drunk or stoned. That is where the problem is. Furthermore - everyone I know who took cannibis went onto heavier drug s but alcohol will kill you too if you overdo it. . . . steve

  • Show:

Recent Your Call discussions

Do you support the strikers?

Your Call, 30/06/2011

Hundreds of thousands of public sector workers are on strike over pensions.

See comments from listeners

Is IVF a right?

Your Call, 07/06/2011

A report says more than 70% of NHS trusts are now ignoring guidance on IVF.

Some have stopped paying for it altogether.

Should it be a right? Can the NHS afford it?

See comments from listeners

"Is it worth getting married?"

Your Call, 27/05/2011

Today the Labour leader Ed Miliband and his partner Justine Thornton are getting hitched.

They already have two children, and he's said recently that unmarried couples can be as solid as married people.

See comments from listeners

Does religion have any place in medicine?

Your Call, 24/05/2011

The General Medical Council gave a GP a written warning for suggesting to a patient that Christianity could help cure him.

Dr Richard Scott told 5 live Breakfast he's appealing against the decision. The GMC say he risked bringing his profession into disrepute by discussing his religion.

See comments from listeners

Are some rapes more serious than others?

Your Call, 19/05/2011

That's what Ken Clarke initially seemed to suggest on Victoria's programme yesterday.

Since then the Justice Secretary has apologised for perhaps giving the wrong impression. He now says he's always believed that all rape is extremely serious.

See comments from listeners

What's the point of Brits learning foreign languages?

Your Call, 09/05/2011

EU officials are telling us our influence abroad is suffering, because as a rule, British people don't speak other languages.

Do we need to?

See comments from listeners

Do the Lib Dems deserve their bad election results?

Your Call, 06/05/2011

It's been a bad night for Nick Clegg.

The results are still coming in but it's clear that the Liberal Democrats have suffered significant losses in the elections.

Have they been asking for it? Or do you think they're just the fall guys for unpopular coalition policies?

See comments from listeners

bbc.co.uk navigation

BBC © 2012 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.