1Xtra's Rewind

On Air Now 04:00 – 07:00

Last updated:
1XTRA NEWS: THE REAL TALK OF THE STREETS
The rise of Afro Reggae
Estelle and TY with members of Afro Reggae
Hear the documentary
Can music get kids out of drugs and violence? TY and Estelle travel to Rio, where a group of musicians are empowering the city's poorest residents.
The members of Afro Reggae were born in favelas - Brazil's shanty towns, where guns, murder and drug trafficking are a part of everyday life. 

Now they're one of the country's biggest bands and using their success to steer kids away from the drug trade and into creativity.

This week TY and Estelle are teaming up with Afro Reggae for their first UK tour. Could what they've done in Brazil work over here?
Can music make a difference? What do you think of Afro Reggae? Could they inspire kids over here? Should homegrown acts follow their example and do more to help youths in the UK?
 
Thanks for your comments. This debate is now closed. A selection of your emails is published below.

H
Yo Trevor, where do you think our kids are getting the ability to 'reflect on the diverse opportunities they have to help them escape a dangerous life caught up in violence and drugs' from? I agree that these brazillian kids probably do have less choices but to say that all of our kids get stuck on the street due to bad attitudes is, quite frankly, RUBBISH! I came from a difficult background & have managed to pull myself away from that & do ok but do you think everyone is able to do that? We're not just talking about poverty. What about violent & sexual abuse, bad parenting, being introduced to drugs, drink & dealing at an early age..... i could go on....

The point is our kids are not born with bad attitudes & we cant just blame them & tell them to simply look at their choices. The help has got to come from somewhere & music would be a bl**dy good start. I love hip hop & always have but some more positive & less sex, drugs & guns wouldnt go a miss. Music is like fashion, young people have a subconscious desire to follow it & if they are being told or shown by their rolemodels that guns etc are cool & normal, yet again we cannot blame them for thinking so. The artists & producers are the adults here, lets start putting some emphasis on them rather than our 'bad attitude' children.

trevor mcdong
I think music can partially influence people's short term attitude and perspective on life, however how can it improve a persons socio-economic situation? It cant pull a man out of a struggle.

Kids over here need to carefully reflect on the diverse oppurtunities they really do have to help them escape a dangerous life caught up in violence and drugs. Kids where these musicians come from have hardly any choice to escape, they're stuck. On the whole, British kids get stuck 'on the street' because of a bad attitude. There are obvious exceptions, however if they approach life postively and with a conscientious attitude, most British kid will do alright. Education on the ghetto lives of Brazilian kids in British schools is a far superior deterrent to music although im not denying bands like this will have a positive impact.

Afro Reggae in pictures
Afro Reggae and local Brazilian kids
Top 5 Documentaries

BBC iD

Sign in

bbc.co.uk navigation

BBC © 2012 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.